MTNL auditors qualify September results over unquantified issues
Key highlights
- MTNL’s standalone results for September 30, 2026 received a qualified review conclusion.
- MTNL reported a Rs 3,964.35 crore net recoverable from BSNL, subject to reconciliation and confirmation.
- Auditors said Rs 352.30 crore in penal guarantee fees should have been recognised as a provision.
- MTNL carried its 3G spectrum licence at Rs 607.88 crore without an impairment assessment at September 30, 2026.
powered by IRIS

Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Limited received a qualified review conclusion on its standalone results for the quarter and half year ended September 30, 2026, as auditors could not quantify several accounting effects, including a Rs 3,964.35 crore net recoverable from BSNL and a Rs 607.88 crore 3G spectrum licence carrying value.
Know Mahanagar Telephone Nigam inside out
Results, valuation, peers and who's buying, in one view.
What did MTNL’s auditors conclude on the September 2026 results?
MTNL’s auditors issued a qualified conclusion because they identified misstatements and other matters whose financial effects could not be ascertained or quantified. The November 13, 2026 review covered the unaudited standalone financial results for the quarter and half year ended September 30, 2026, under Regulations 33 and 52 of the Securities and Exchange Board of India listing regulations.
The auditors said that, except for the effects of the identified and unquantified matters, nothing had come to their attention suggesting the statement was not prepared in material compliance with applicable Indian Accounting Standards. The work was a limited review under Standard on Review Engagements 2410, which provides moderate assurance and is narrower than an audit conducted under statutory auditing standards.
The matters extend across counterparty balances, receivables, provisions, billing, leases, tax and spectrum accounting. One quantified finding was the treatment of Rs 352.30 crore in penal guarantee fees: auditors said MTNL should have recognised this amount as a provision, meaning liabilities and expenses were understated and profit was overstated by the same amount.
The qualified conclusion also accompanies an emphasis of matter on MTNL’s ability to continue as a going concern. At September 30, 2026, MTNL reported negative net worth of Rs 31,618.15 crore, while the auditors cited bank instalment defaults of Rs 2,246 crore and term-loan interest defaults of Rs 1,938 crore. MTNL nevertheless prepared the results on a going-concern basis, considering the Government of India’s majority shareholding.
Which MTNL balances with BSNL and DoT remain unresolved?
MTNL’s balances with Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited, or BSNL, remain unresolved because the Rs 5,980.81 crore gross receivable and Rs 2,016.46 crore payable were subject to reconciliation and confirmation. This leaves a reported Rs 3,964.35 crore net recoverable, including Rs 2.03 crore of service-tax recoverable, but auditors could not assess its recoverability or correctness amid pending disputes, claims and counterclaims.
MTNL also reported Rs 683.13 crore receivable from the Department of Telecommunications, or DoT, and Rs 1,196.44 crore payable to it. The auditor’s report states a Rs 513.31 crore net payable, subject to reconciliation and confirmation, and says it could not determine the balances’ correctness or their impact on the September 2026 standalone results.
The qualification also covers incomplete confirmation and reconciliation of trade receivables, deposits with government departments, operator claims, trade payables and other party balances. MTNL had developed a reconciliation and confirmation process by September 30, 2026, but auditors said complete confirmations and reconciliations had not yet been obtained, preventing quantification of the outcome.
A separate issue involved Rs 48.58 crore of subscriber receipts that could not be linked to corresponding receivables and were shown as liabilities. Of that amount, Rs 3.09 crore related to the Delhi Wireless Unit and had been outstanding for more than three years. Auditors said it should have been written back under MTNL’s accounting policy, causing trade receivables and current liabilities to be overstated pending reconciliation and accounting treatment.
Got a follow-up? Ask IRIS
How could MTNL’s provisions, receivables and liabilities change?
MTNL’s expected-credit-loss provision may require reassessment because it recognised expected credit loss, or ECL, only on trade receivables rather than other relevant financial assets such as claims recoverable. MTNL had recognised a Rs 181.66 crore provision at September 30, 2026 for amounts recoverable for more than three years, but auditors said the approach did not comply with Indian Accounting Standard 109, Financial Instruments.
The auditors required a comprehensive ECL review under Indian Accounting Standard 109 before determining the effect on claims recoverable, loss allowance and reported loss. The report does not calculate any additional provision beyond Rs 181.66 crore; it says the financial effect cannot be ascertained until the broader review is completed.
The Rs 352.30 crore penal guarantee-fee issue is more specific. MTNL had provided for Rs 352.30 crore of guarantee fees payable to the Government of India but disclosed an equal amount of penal guarantee fees as a contingent liability. Auditors said the obligation had crystallised under a government directive and was reliably measurable, requiring a provision under Indian Accounting Standard 37.
Other stated adjustments include Rs 11.64 crore of accrued liabilities outstanding for over three years. Auditors said these liabilities should have been written back under MTNL’s policy, resulting in overstated current liabilities and other income. They also could not quantify the impact of unpaid goods and services tax, or GST, on electricity charges recovered from tenants for the period ended September 30, 2026.
Why did auditors question MTNL’s billing, leases and spectrum accounting?
MTNL’s manual average billing in certain Mumbai and Delhi units resulted in overstated revenue after customers migrated to BSNL, according to the auditors. The review listed Rs 0.46 crore of income for Mumbai Wireless, Rs 1.39 crore for Delhi Wireless and Rs 0.12 crore of Delhi Wireless expense. Without system-driven billing based on actual usage, auditors could not assess the accuracy or completeness of revenue and related receivables.
Interconnect usage charges, or IUC, expenses were booked provisionally using April 2025 values, despite the customer migration. Auditors said such charges should be reduced in proportion to migrated customers, but could not quantify the effect at September 30, 2026. They also noted that GST had not been discharged on accrued IUC income and on certain accrued rental, electricity and water charges billed to BSNL.
The 3G spectrum licence had a carrying value of Rs 607.88 crore at September 30, 2026, against total mobile revenue of Rs 6.87 crore from April through September 2026. The licence remains valid until January-February 2029. Auditors said MTNL should have performed an impairment assessment under Indian Accounting Standard 36, Impairment of Assets, but no assessment had been undertaken and the resulting effect remained unquantified.
MTNL’s lease accounting was also not verifiable because adequate supporting documents and updated lease records were unavailable. Auditors said entries relied on old data that did not reflect new leases, expired leases or revised rents, contrary to Indian Accounting Standard 116, Leases. They additionally cited unreconciled operative and inactive bank accounts at September 30, 2026, with any eventual financial impact still undetermined.
Conclusion
MTNL’s qualified review combines specific accounting corrections with wider uncertainties that remain unmeasured. The Rs 352.30 crore penal guarantee-fee provision is a stated adjustment, while the Rs 3,964.35 crore BSNL net recoverable, Rs 513.31 crore DoT net payable, broader ECL model, billing records, lease data and 3G licence impairment assessment remain subject to unresolved review or reconciliation.
The next disclosures to watch are progress on the BSNL and DoT reconciliations, the required impairment assessment of the Rs 607.88 crore 3G licence before its January-February 2029 validity end, and MTNL’s lender-bank resolution efforts. MTNL said all bank loan accounts became non-performing at September 30, 2026 after repayment and interest defaults totalling Rs 4,183.21 crore, and that it had initiated discussions with lenders on possible resolution and settlement.


