M K Sons Fine Jewels contests Rs 3.74 crore tax demand in appeal
Key highlights
- M K Sons is appealing a Rs 3.74 crore Assessment Year 2017-18 tax demand linked to Rs 4.99785 crore of demonetisation-period cash deposits.
- Tax authorities classified the deposits as unexplained money under Section 69A after rejecting the company’s books under Section 145(3).
- M K Sons says the deposits were genuine jewellery-sale proceeds supported by sales records, tax returns, bank statements and reconciliations.
- A February 18, 2025 notice specified Rs 3.7397665 crore as payable, while a recovery stay was granted on January 23, 2020.
powered by IRIS

M K Sons Fine Jewels is contesting a Rs 3.74 crore income-tax demand for Assessment Year 2017-18 after tax authorities rejected its books and treated Rs 4.99785 crore of demonetisation-period cash deposits as unexplained money. M K Sons says the deposits were documented jewellery-sale proceeds, and its appeal remains pending.
Why is M K Sons contesting the Rs 3.74 crore tax demand?
M K Sons is contesting the demand because the tax assessment classified its demonetisation-period cash deposits as unexplained money rather than recorded jewellery-sale proceeds. The Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, Mumbai, passed the Assessment Year 2017-18 order on November 28, 2019 under Section 143(3) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, after rejecting the company’s books of account under Section 145(3).
The assessment treated Rs 4.99785 crore of deposits as unexplained money under Section 69A and applied Section 115BBE of the Income-tax Act. Section 69A concerns money owned by a taxpayer that is not recorded in the books and whose nature and source are not satisfactorily explained. Section 115BBE governs tax on specified income that includes such unexplained amounts.
The November 28, 2019 demand notice initially determined Rs 4.2942955 crore as payable. The litigation table reports Rs 3.74 crore as the amount in dispute or demanded, while a February 18, 2025 notice under Section 221(1) specified Rs 3.7397665 crore as payable. The disclosure therefore distinguishes the original demand from the later amount specified as payable.
What is M K Sons' explanation for the cash deposits?
M K Sons says the Rs 4.99785 crore of cash deposits represented genuine proceeds from jewellery sales. In its December 9, 2019 appeal, M K Sons said the transactions were supported by its books of account, stock and sales registers, purchase records, value-added tax returns, bank statements and reconciliation statements.
M K Sons also contends that the Assessing Officer wrongly invoked Sections 145(3), 69A and 115BBE without identifying specific defects in its books. Section 145(3) permits the rejection of accounts where the Assessing Officer is dissatisfied with their correctness or completeness, or where prescribed accounting standards or methods have not been followed. The company’s position therefore challenges both the evidence assessment and the legal basis for rejecting its records.
The company filed its appeal under Section 246A before the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals), the provision that permits appeals against specified assessment and demand orders. The Assessing Officer and the Principal Commissioner of Income-tax granted a stay on January 23, 2020. The disclosed stay concerns recovery action and does not resolve whether the deposits were jewellery-sale proceeds or unexplained money.
Got a follow-up? Ask IRIS
How does the demand compare with M K Sons' other tax matters?
M K Sons' Rs 3.74 crore Assessment Year 2017-18 case is its largest quantified company tax matter in the disclosed litigation section. The section lists five direct-tax matters filed against M K Sons and one direct-tax appeal filed by M K Sons, with only the Assessment Year 2012-13 matter also carrying a quantified amount in the table.
For Assessment Year 2012-13, the Income Tax Officer, Mumbai, added Rs 3 crore to M K Sons' total income through an order dated November 8, 2017. The resulting demand was Rs 1.635536 crore, and a Section 221(1) notice dated October 21, 2021 stated that Rs 1.2548214 crore was payable. The National Faceless Appeal Centre, Delhi dismissed M K Sons' appeal on November 3, 2025, but the matter remains pending according to the disclosure.
The NIL entries in the litigation table do not mean that no proceedings exist. For Assessment Year 2018-19, the Centralised Processing Centre proposed an adjustment of Rs 19,061 on February 16, 2019, and for Assessment Year 2019-20 it proposed Rs 34,454 on February 14, 2020. The Assessment Year 2022-23 matter involves a proposed adjustment of Rs 5.14377 lakh, but the disclosure says that no order or demand notice had been issued as of its date.
What does the disclosure say about the scope of litigation?
M K Sons reports NIL criminal litigation, statutory or regulatory-authority actions, indirect-tax liabilities and other pending litigation in the company categories disclosed. It also reports NIL in those categories for litigation filed by M K Sons, leaving the Assessment Year 2017-18 direct-tax appeal as the sole quantified tax matter filed by the company.
The disclosure follows a materiality policy adopted by M K Sons' board on March 9, 2026. Under that policy, pending litigation involving the company, promoters and directors is considered material when the aggregate claim exceeds the lowest of 2% of turnover, 2% of net worth, or 5% of the average absolute profit or loss after tax for the preceding three annual restated financial statements.
The policy also permits disclosure where an amount cannot be quantified or falls below those thresholds but the outcome may materially affect business, operations, performance, prospects, financial position or reputation. The stated absence of other material claims is therefore a disclosure assessment under the March 9, 2026 policy, not a determination of the Assessment Year 2017-18 appeal.
What could change the status of M K Sons' appeal?
M K Sons' appeal could change the dispute because it challenges the rejected books, the Section 69A treatment of the deposits and the Section 115BBE tax treatment. A decision in the appeal would need to address the company’s claim that its records document the source of the Rs 4.99785 crore deposited during the demonetisation period.
The February 18, 2025 Section 221(1) notice is the latest amount-specific update disclosed for the case, specifying Rs 3.7397665 crore as payable. The January 23, 2020 stay remains relevant to recovery, but it neither cancels the demand nor establishes the company’s explanation for the deposits.
Conclusion
The disclosed dispute turns on whether Rs 4.99785 crore of demonetisation-period deposits can be accepted as jewellery-sale proceeds supported by M K Sons' business records, or treated as unexplained money after the rejection of those records. The Rs 3.74 crore litigation-table amount makes the Assessment Year 2017-18 appeal the largest quantified company tax matter in the disclosure.
The next development to watch is an appellate outcome on M K Sons' December 9, 2019 appeal, particularly its challenge to the use of Sections 145(3), 69A and 115BBE. Until a decision, settlement or further tax-process update is disclosed, the February 18, 2025 notice specifying Rs 3.7397665 crore as payable remains the latest amount-specific case update.


