Praxis FY25 audit disclaimer flags Rs 101 crore deposit
Key highlights
- Praxis’s FY25 auditors disclaimed an opinion because sufficient audit evidence was unavailable for several material balances.
- The largest disclosed audit issue was a Rs 101 crore security deposit receivable from Future Enterprises Limited.
- Trade payables of Rs 94.17 crore were subject to confirmations and reconciliations at March 31, 2025.
- Praxis reported a FY25 cash loss of Rs 45.42 crore, compared with Rs 49.42 crore in the preceding financial year.
powered by IRIS

Praxis Home Retail Limited’s auditors disclaimed an opinion on its financial statements for the year ended March 31, 2025, citing insufficient audit evidence on a Rs 101 crore security deposit from Future Enterprises Limited and other unquantified balances. The auditors also reported a material uncertainty over Praxis’s ability to continue as a going concern.
Know Praxis Home Retail inside out
Results, valuation, peers and who's buying, in one view.
Why did Praxis receive a FY25 audit disclaimer?
Praxis received a disclaimer of opinion for FY25 because its statutory auditors said they could not obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence to provide a basis for an opinion on the financial statements. The matters included the Rs 101 crore related-party deposit, a Rs 94.17 crore trade-payables balance awaiting confirmation, potential impairment of Rs 125.81 crore of right-of-use assets, and inventory at closed stores.
The auditors said the possible effects of these matters on FY25 loss, earnings per share, other equity and asset values could not be ascertained. A disclaimer means the auditors did not express an opinion on the FY25 statements, rather than expressing an opinion with a limited qualification on a particular accounting matter.
Several central matters were also disclaimed in the audit report for the year ended March 31, 2024. The FY25 report specifically identified the expected-credit-loss assessment on the Future Enterprises Limited deposit, trade-payable confirmations, write-backs and right-of-use asset impairment as matters carried forward from FY24.
What is the issue with Praxis’s Future Enterprises Limited deposit?
Praxis’s Rs 101 crore security deposit was receivable from Future Enterprises Limited, a related party, under a lease arrangement that matured on November 30, 2022. For FY25, the auditors said Praxis had not identified or recognised an expected credit loss, or ECL, on the receivable, which they said did not conform with Indian Accounting Standard 109, Financial Instruments.
Management told the auditors that Praxis had not received an appropriate or adequate response from the lessor about refunding the deposit. The auditors also referred to Future Enterprises Limited’s financial position, material uncertainty over its ability to continue as a going concern, and the appointment of a resolution professional by the National Company Law Tribunal under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016.
The auditors therefore said they could not determine whether the Rs 101 crore balance would be fully recoverable or quantify any ECL provision required. They added that resolving the transactions could lead to material adjustments to the recorded deposit, provision for lease rentals, unrecorded assets and possible tax implications.
The Letter of Offer later includes a status table that records “Yes” against provision recognised for the Rs 101 crore Future Enterprises Limited security amount and describes a potential loss of Rs 101 crore. The supplied disclosure does not state the date, accounting period or amount of that provision, while the FY25 audit observation says no ECL had been recognised in the audited FY25 statements.
Got a follow-up? Ask IRIS
Which liabilities and write-backs remained unverified at Praxis?
The auditors cited an interlocutory application filed on January 9, 2025 by Future Enterprises Limited’s resolution professional before the National Company Law Tribunal, Mumbai Bench. The application sought Rs 45.77 crore in lease rentals from Praxis for in-store retail infrastructure assets leased by Future Enterprises Limited.
The audit report said the possible provision for these lease rentals had not been recorded because the amount was not readily ascertainable. Consequently, auditors could not measure the resulting effects on the Rs 101 crore deposit, lease obligations, unrecorded assets or the FY25 loss and earnings per share.
Trade payables of Rs 94.17 crore were subject to confirmations and reconciliations as at March 31, 2025. Auditors said they could not comment on the correctness of these figures, whether adjustments were necessary, or whether the related financial-statement disclosures were complete. This confirmation issue had also been disclaimed in the FY24 audit report.
Praxis wrote back trade payables and provisions totalling Rs 37.71 crore in FY25, including Rs 26.94 crore relating to related-party balances and provisions. The auditors said the reasons for these write-backs were not known to them. The disclosed amount included a related party under corporate insolvency resolution whose resolution professional had claimed Rs 23.21 crore plus interest, a claim Praxis denied and did not recognise.
What did auditors report on assets, inventory and going concern?
The auditors said inventory shortages, liquidity constraints and losses at most stores were impairment indicators for Praxis’s right-of-use, or ROU, assets. Praxis reported ROU assets of Rs 125.81 crore as at March 31, 2025, but had not performed an impairment assessment, leaving any effect on loss, earnings per share, carrying value and other equity unquantified.
Store closures created a separate inventory-evidence issue. Inventory valued at Rs 111.32 lakh at some closed stores remained under the respective lessors’ control, and Praxis could not physically verify it or make an appropriate provision. Auditors could not determine whether that inventory was fully recoverable or calculate a provision, if required.
Under the Companies (Auditor’s Report) Order, 2020, or CARO, the auditors also reported that discrepancies identified during physical inventory verification exceeded 10% of aggregate inventory value, though they said those discrepancies had been dealt with in the books. This differs from the Rs 111.32 lakh closed-store inventory issue, where auditors said they could not obtain sufficient evidence through physical verification.
The CARO report further said accounting software audit trails, also called edit logs, had not operated during the year for all relevant transactions and had not been duly maintained and preserved under applicable record-retention requirements. For one system hosted by a third-party service provider, the independent service auditor’s report was unavailable to the auditors.
Can Praxis continue as a going concern after FY25?
The auditors said material uncertainty existed that might cast significant doubt on Praxis’s ability to continue as a going concern. Praxis incurred a FY25 cash loss of Rs 45.42 crore, had negative net worth at the balance-sheet date, and reported current liabilities exceeding current assets by Rs 93.11 crore, excluding specified audit observations.
The FY25 cash loss was lower than the Rs 49.42 crore cash loss reported in the immediately preceding financial year. The Rs 4 crore reduction does not resolve the audit uncertainty because the auditors said both years’ cash-loss figures excluded the effects of unquantified modifications in the audit reports.
Praxis had also received notice of an application under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 from an operational creditor. In view of the cash loss, negative net worth, current-liability excess and creditor action, the auditors said they could not obtain sufficient evidence on whether Praxis could service debts, realise assets and discharge liabilities as they fall due over the next 12 months.
Conclusion
Praxis’s FY25 disclaimer reflects multiple unresolved accounting and evidence issues, not only the Rs 101 crore Future Enterprises Limited deposit. The Rs 94.17 crore of unconfirmed payables, Rs 37.71 crore of write-backs, Rs 125.81 crore of ROU assets without impairment testing and Rs 111.32 lakh of inaccessible inventory all left possible adjustments unquantified.
The next disclosures to watch are the treatment and recoverability of the Rs 101 crore deposit, the January 9, 2025 lease-rental application for Rs 45.77 crore, and any resolution of the Rs 94.17 crore payable reconciliations. Praxis’s ability during the next 12 months to service debts and settle liabilities also remains an unresolved matter identified by the auditors.


