Polycab gets Rs 2.78 crore CIRP admission set aside by NCLAT
Key highlights
- NCLAT set aside Polycab India’s CIRP admission on October 30, 2026, reversing the October 7, 2026 NCLT order.
- Asier Metals’ insolvency claim against Polycab was Rs 2.78 crore for aluminium ingot supplies.
- Polycab cited pending credit notes, ledger reconciliation and an Rs 80 lakh detention and demurrage adjustment as evidence of a pre-existing dispute.
- NCLAT left the final liability unresolved and said the commercial accounting dispute must be addressed in a competent forum.
powered by IRIS

Polycab India Limited had its admission to the corporate insolvency resolution process, or CIRP, set aside by the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal, or NCLAT, on October 30, 2026. The tribunal found a plausible pre-existing dispute over Asier Metals Private Limited’s Rs 2.78 crore claim, including pending credit notes, account reconciliation and Rs 80 lakh of detention and demurrage adjustments.
Know Polycab India inside out
Results, valuation, peers and who's buying, in one view.
Why did NCLAT set aside Polycab’s CIRP admission?
NCLAT set aside Polycab’s CIRP admission because the record showed a genuine dispute that required examination beyond the limited insolvency-admission process. The appellate tribunal allowed Polycab’s appeal against the October 7, 2026 order of the National Company Law Tribunal, Ahmedabad Bench, which had admitted Polycab to CIRP on Asier Metals’ Section 9 application.
The dispute arose from a commercial relationship beginning around December 2019 for Asier Metals’ supply of non-ferrous metal ingots to Polycab. Purchase orders contemplated advance payments for monthly shipments, provisional invoices and final pricing adjustments through credit and debit notes. The parties also reconciled their accounts at intervals, making the calculation of the claimed unpaid balance central to the case.
Asier Metals issued its Section 8 demand notice on August 6, 2026, claiming Rs 2.78 crore for aluminium ingot supplies. Polycab issued a without-prejudice holding response on August 19, 2026 and a detailed reply on September 2, 2026. Asier Metals filed its Section 9 application on August 24, 2026, before Polycab’s detailed response but after the holding response.
What dispute did Polycab raise against Asier Metals?
Polycab disputed whether Rs 2.78 crore remained payable after agreed credit notes, reconciliation and delay-related adjustments. NCLAT identified communications concerning provisional billing, discounts, detention and demurrage costs, pending credit notes and the final amount payable. It held that these documents created a plausible contention requiring further investigation.
A February 2, 2026 email from Polycab said it would not make further ingot purchases because material for which it had made an advance payment on January 19, 2026 had not been delivered. Polycab said the delay had caused a loss of United States dollar 12 per tonne. In a February 3, 2026 response, Asier Metals said it would work out detention and demurrage with Polycab and try to resolve the matter in current supplies.
In a July 22, 2026 email responding to a payment reminder for Rs 2.78 crore, Polycab said mutually agreed credit notes were still to be issued. It stated that payments processed in June 2026 had been adjusted against purchase transactions and that no amount was payable to Asier Metals from Polycab’s side. Polycab also requested an Rs 80 lakh credit note for detention and demurrage and sought reconciliation of the ledgers.
NCLAT did not rule that Polycab’s account calculation would necessarily prevail in a final commercial dispute. Its finding was that the correspondence showed a real dispute over credit-note adjustments, delayed supply costs and reconciliation. Under the test applied by the tribunal, Polycab was not required to establish at the Section 9 stage that its defence would ultimately succeed.
Got a follow-up? Ask IRIS
What did NCLAT find wrong with the NCLT order?
NCLAT found that NCLT had not adequately examined contemporaneous communications placed on record by Polycab. NCLT had treated correspondence relating to provisional billing, credit notes and other commercial issues as either normal business exchanges or unrelated to the June 8 and June 25, 2026 purchase orders underlying the insolvency application.
The appellate tribunal disagreed after considering the February 2, February 3 and July 22, 2026 communications. It said the February emails showed Polycab had raised delayed-supply concerns and Asier Metals had agreed to work out detention and demurrage. It also said the July email evidenced a continuing dispute over credit notes and ledger reconciliation before the August 6, 2026 demand notice.
Counsel for Asier Metals acknowledged before NCLAT that the communications relied on by Polycab to show pre-existing disputes had not been examined in the NCLT order. NCLAT said the issue was not whether Polycab had conclusively proved its defence. The adjudicating authority instead had to decide whether the claimed dispute was plausible rather than spurious, hypothetical, illusory or unsupported by evidence.
NCLT had noted that Polycab had not raised a debit note and had not sufficiently disputed quantity, quality or delayed-supply charges. NCLAT held that the available email record, including Polycab’s Rs 80 lakh request for a detention and demurrage credit note, was sufficient to show a dispute over commercial adjustments. It concluded that the statutory consequence under Section 9(5)(ii)(d) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, or IBC, should have followed.
Could Polycab rely on a dispute after the demand-notice deadline?
Yes, NCLAT held that Polycab could rely on evidence of a pre-existing dispute despite its detailed reply being sent on September 2, 2026, after the 10-day period following the August 6 demand notice. Its August 19 holding response had expressly stated that none of Asier Metals’ assertions was admitted and was issued without prejudice to Polycab’s rights and remedies.
NCLAT treated the August 19 response as a notice of dispute under Section 9(5)(ii)(d) of the IBC even though it did not provide the detailed particulars later set out on September 2. The tribunal also applied its earlier ruling that a corporate debtor is not barred from presenting material on a pre-existing dispute before the adjudicating authority solely because it did not submit a formal detailed reply within 10 days.
Polycab also disputed Asier Metals’ claim through the National e-Governance Services Limited, or NeSL, information-utility system on September 11, 2026. NCLT had regarded that entry as too late to establish a pre-existing dispute. NCLAT noted Polycab’s submission that the relevant financial records had themselves been filed on NeSL after the demand notice, so the timing of the entry could not displace the earlier commercial correspondence.
The tribunal focused on the chronology of the underlying documents, including communications dated January 19, February 2, February 3, June 4, June 11, June 16, June 30, July 1 and July 22, 2026. Those records preceded the August 6 demand notice and dealt with the same subjects of credit notes, pricing adjustments, delayed supplies and reconciliation. NCLAT found that sequence sufficient to require rejection of the Section 9 application.
What does the order mean for Asier Metals’ Rs 2.78 crore claim?
The order means that Asier Metals’ Rs 2.78 crore claim cannot support Polycab’s CIRP admission on the record assessed in the appeal. NCLAT set aside the October 7, 2026 admission because Section 9(5)(ii)(d) requires rejection where the operational creditor has received a notice of dispute or the record otherwise shows a genuine pre-existing dispute.
The order does not decide the final accounting between Polycab and Asier Metals. It leaves unresolved whether credit notes should be issued, whether the Rs 80 lakh detention and demurrage adjustment is due, and what amount may remain after ledger reconciliation. NCLAT said those matters required adjudication by a competent court rather than determination through insolvency admission proceedings.
Conclusion
The October 30, 2026 ruling removes Polycab from CIRP because the Rs 2.78 crore operational-debt claim was accompanied by documented disputes over the amount itself. The appellate tribunal found that Polycab’s pre-demand-notice emails on delayed delivery, agreed credit notes, detention and demurrage, and account reconciliation met the IBC threshold for a plausible dispute.
The next issue is whether Polycab and Asier Metals reconcile the ledgers and resolve the pending credit-note and delay-cost claims, including Polycab’s Rs 80 lakh request. NCLAT’s order leaves the underlying commercial claim open for determination in a competent forum while setting aside the October 7, 2026 CIRP admission.


