Twinstar Technologies Limited Plan Remanded by Supreme Court
Key highlights
- The Supreme Court upheld the remand of Twinstar's ₹2,962.02 crore plan for 13 Videocon group companies.
- The plan had received 95.09% CoC approval but did not attain finality because it was under statutory challenge.
- The Court held that dissenting financial creditors cannot be compelled to accept long-term NCDs instead of monetary payment.
- Foreign oil and gas interests in four Brazil concessions and Indonesia's Nunukan block remain outside Videocon Industries Limited's insolvency estate.
powered by IRIS

Twinstar Technologies Limited's ₹2,962.02 crore resolution plan for Videocon Industries Limited and 12 group companies has been returned to lenders after the Supreme Court upheld its remand to the Committee of Creditors, finding that dissenting financial creditors were not assured the monetary payment required under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code.
Know Videocon Industries inside out
Results, valuation, peers and who's buying, in one view.
Why did the Supreme Court send the Videocon plan back to creditors?
The Supreme Court dismissed Twinstar's appeals against the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal's decision to set aside approval of its plan and return the matter to the Committee of Creditors, or CoC, for reconsideration. The ruling concerns the consolidated corporate insolvency resolution process for Videocon Industries Limited and 12 other Videocon group companies.
A Bench of Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha and Justice Alok Aradhe upheld the NCLAT's January 5, 2022 order. The appellate tribunal had concluded that the plan did not comply with provisions of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, or IBC, and directed the CoC to reconsider it and complete the resolution process in accordance with the law.
Twinstar was the successful resolution applicant for the 13 companies. Its plan had received approval from 95.09% of creditors, according to the case record cited in the reported proceedings. But that approval remained under statutory challenge before the NCLAT and had not attained finality.
The Supreme Court said that once an appeal against plan approval is allowed on the limited grounds available under Section 61(3) of the IBC, merely setting aside the approval could leave the insolvency process without a workable next step. It held that remand to the CoC can therefore be appropriate, subject to safeguards.
How did the plan fail the dissenting creditor payment test?
The Court held that Twinstar's plan did not meet statutory requirements because it proposed to discharge a substantial part of dissenting financial creditors' claims through non-convertible debentures, or NCDs, rather than through payment in money. The debentures were redeemable over several years, including a reported six-year period.
Relying on the precedent in Jaypee Kensington Boulevard Apartments Welfare Association v. NBCC (India) Limited, the Bench said the payment contemplated for dissenting financial creditors under the IBC must be monetary. A long-dated instrument such as redeemable NCDs could not substitute for this requirement.
The Court also found that the plan did not secure the priority required for dissenting financial creditors under Regulation 38(1)(b) of the CIRP Regulations. This regulatory protection is intended to ensure that creditors voting against a plan receive the treatment prescribed by the insolvency framework.
Got a follow-up? Ask IRIS
What power of remand did the Supreme Court affirm for the NCLAT?
The Supreme Court affirmed that the NCLAT can remit an approved resolution plan to the CoC when it allows an appeal on grounds recognised by Section 61(3) of the IBC. The Court described remand as a consequence that can be necessary after a plan approval is set aside, rather than an authority excluded by the insolvency statute.
The Bench also rejected the argument that the CoC becomes functus officio, meaning that it has exhausted its role, immediately after approving a plan. It held that the CoC continues to exist during the corporate insolvency resolution process until the plan is implemented or a liquidation order is passed.
This distinction was important because approval of Twinstar's plan was challenged and the NCLAT had directed maintenance of status quo ante. In those circumstances, the CoC could reconsider a plan that had been found non-compliant. The Court distinguished Ebix Singapore Pvt. Ltd. v. Committee of Creditors of Educomp Solutions Ltd., which concerned a resolution applicant seeking to withdraw or modify its own plan.
For lenders and resolution applicants, the judgment clarifies that CoC approval does not by itself make a plan immune from correction through the appellate process. At the same time, the Court tied remand to the statutory appellate structure and to identified non-compliance, rather than treating it as a routine second round of commercial decision-making.
Why were Videocon's overseas oil and gas assets kept outside the process?
The Supreme Court upheld the exclusion of foreign oil and gas assets held through Videocon subsidiaries from Videocon Industries Limited's insolvency estate. The assets include participating interests in four concessions in Brazil and the Nunukan block in Indonesia, held through subsidiaries including wholly owned VOVL Limited.
The Court accepted that a holding company and its subsidiaries are separate legal entities. Accordingly, the foreign assets owned by the subsidiaries could not automatically be treated as assets of Videocon Industries Limited merely because of the corporate relationship within the group.
The Bench upheld the NCLAT's May 14, 2026 judgment on the overseas assets and declined to interfere with a transaction approved in VOVL's insolvency process. It dismissed the connected appeal of former Videocon promoter Venugopal Dhoot, while leaving open remedies available under law.
The Court also dismissed the appeal of the VIL Vendors Association, which represents operational creditors, with liberty to pursue remedies available under the IBC. Separately, GAIL's claim is to be dealt with by the resolution professional, while the Union of India may place its contentions before the resolution professional and the adjudicating authority.
Conclusion
The ruling leaves Twinstar's ₹2,962.02 crore proposal without final approval and returns the Videocon resolution exercise to the CoC. Its central legal finding is that dissenting financial creditors cannot be required to accept long-term NCDs in place of the monetary payment and priority protections required by the IBC and CIRP Regulations.
The next step is for the CoC to reconsider the plan and complete the insolvency process in line with the Court's ruling. Attention will remain on the revised treatment of dissenting lenders, the resolution professional's handling of pending claims including GAIL's, and proceedings before the adjudicating authority where relevant parties present their statutory contentions.


