Basai Steels faces Rs 157.74 crore merger tax challenge
Key highlights
- The Income Tax Department identified Rs 157.74 crore of unabsorbed depreciation as the central issue in the Basai Steels amalgamation.
- The department said the depreciation pool could offset more than two full years of A-One Steels’ taxable income.
- Basai Steels said A-One Steels holds 78.14% of its paid-up equity share capital following a 13 April 2018 resolution-plan approval.
- A-One Steels undertook not to claim Basai Steels’ unabsorbed additional depreciation under Section 115BAA.
powered by IRIS

Basai Steels faces an Income Tax Department objection in amalgamation proceedings recorded on 20 November 2026 over Rs 157.74 crore of unabsorbed depreciation, which the department said could extinguish more than two full years of A-One Steels’ taxable income. Basai Steels said any tax benefit depends on statutory conditions and independent assessment.
Know A-One Steels India inside out
Results, valuation, peers and who's buying, in one view.
Why did the Income Tax Department oppose the Basai Steels merger?
The Income Tax Department opposed the scheme because it regarded Rs 157.74 crore of unabsorbed depreciation as its real subject matter. In an affidavit dated 18 August 2026, the Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax, Circle-3(4), Hyderabad, said the amount was available for carry-forward to assessment year 2026-27 and could offset more than two full years of A-One Steels’ entire taxable income.
The department also said Basai Steels had not carried on manufacturing activity since financial year 2021-22, corresponding to assessment year 2022-23. It alleged that depreciation was being charged year after year against a business that did not exist, and said the commercial benefits cited for the amalgamation had already been achieved through the existing lease arrangement.
The department further argued that the depreciation pool arose under Basai Steels’ erstwhile management in a manufacturing business it said had been abandoned. It described the attribute as stranded in a corporate shell and said transferring it to a profit-earning transferee could use the tribunal’s sanction as an instrument of tax avoidance, to the detriment of public revenue.
How did Basai Steels answer the tax objections?
Basai Steels said the scheme neither creates nor independently confers a tax benefit on A-One Steels. It said accumulated losses and unabsorbed depreciation in an amalgamation are governed by Section 72A and other applicable provisions of the Income Tax Act, 1961, meaning any benefit would arise only if statutory conditions are fulfilled.
Basai Steels said the absence of manufacturing from financial year 2021-22 must be assessed in the context of its insolvency proceedings. It said A-One Steels was identified as strategic investor under a resolution plan approved by the tribunal on 13 April 2018 in CA No. 86 of 2018 in CP(IB) No. 77/09/HDB/2017, and currently holds 78.14% of its paid-up equity share capital.
Basai Steels said the lease arrangement was included in the approved resolution plan, under which rental income from leasing the facilities was envisaged as an immediate revenue source. It added that A-One Steels had made substantial investments in plant and machinery, buildings, electrical installations and other fixed assets at the Bellary manufacturing facility, while the industrial undertaking and existing manufacturing assets remained with Basai Steels.
Basai Steels said the merger would eliminate the separation between ownership of the undertaking and the investments, operations and development associated with it. Its position was that placing these elements in one entity would provide legal, financial and operational integration that could not be achieved by retaining the lease alone; it said the depreciation and business-loss claims remained subject to income-tax proceedings.
Got a follow-up? Ask IRIS
Can A-One Steels claim the full depreciation pool?
A-One Steels cannot treat the full Rs 157.74 crore as automatically available, according to Basai Steels’ reply. Basai Steels said any claim for accumulated losses or unabsorbed depreciation would be made under applicable law and settled jurisprudence, then be subject to scrutiny and verification by the revenue authorities.
A specific restriction concerns A-One Steels’ election of the concessional regime under Section 115BAA of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The department said a substantial part of the pool could not be set off under that regime, and Basai Steels replied that A-One Steels would comply with Section 115BAA in full and would not claim unabsorbed additional depreciation in Basai Steels’ books.
The department also challenged whether Section 72A conditions were, or could be, met and raised the possible application of the General Anti-Avoidance Rule under Chapter X-A of the Income Tax Act, 1961. Basai Steels said it had addressed the Section 72A objections in its reply dated 4 September 2026 and had responded to the General Anti-Avoidance Rule point in paragraph 15 of that reply.
What safeguards did the Income Tax Department request?
The Income Tax Department asked the tribunal to decline sanction of the amalgamation, saying its predominant purpose was income-tax avoidance and that it was contrary to public policy. Alternatively, it requested an express direction that sanction would not adjudicate or confer any entitlement to carry forward or set off Basai Steels’ accumulated losses or unabsorbed depreciation, including Rs 157.74 crore.
The department said entitlement should instead be determined independently by the assessing officer under Section 72A, Rule 9C of the Income Tax Rules, 1962, and Section 115BAA. It also sought to preserve the tax authorities’ powers under Chapter X-A and all assessment, reassessment, recovery and penalty rights for every assessment year concerning Basai Steels and A-One Steels.
The department requested that A-One Steels be made liable for Basai Steels’ past, present and future tax dues, interest and penalties, including liabilities that could arise from the investigation under Section 210 of the Companies Act, 2013. It stated that, based on available records, no demand was outstanding for recovery against Basai Steels at that date, but said its objection focused on potential tax avoidance and protection of future revenue.
If the scheme became effective, the department sought a requirement for A-One Steels to file a complete statement of assets, liabilities and tax attributes acquired from Basai Steels within 30 days with the jurisdictional assessing officer. It also requested the computation and certificate contemplated by Rule 9C; Basai Steels said A-One Steels had already undertaken to preserve the revenue’s rights and meet future demands as successor in interest.
Conclusion
The disclosed dispute concerns both the availability and the permitted use of Rs 157.74 crore of unabsorbed depreciation after the proposed amalgamation. The department says the pool points to a tax-avoidance purpose because Basai Steels has not conducted manufacturing since financial year 2021-22, while Basai Steels says the transaction would consolidate ownership, investments and operations following the 2018 resolution-plan structure.
The next disclosed issue is whether any sanction preserves the assessing officer’s independent role under Section 72A, Rule 9C and Section 115BAA. If the scheme becomes effective, the department has requested a 30-day filing by A-One Steels detailing the assets, liabilities and tax attributes taken over, alongside the required Rule 9C computation and certificate.


