Crystal Crop CBI chargesheet alleges Rs 75.531 crore refunds
Key highlights
- The CBI chargesheet dated December 24, 2021 alleges Rs 75.531 crore of wrongful TED refunds by Crystal Crop and other accused persons.
- Crystal Crop received Rs 110.325 crore through 101 TED-refund applications sanctioned and released between 2014 and 2016.
- Sixty-eight applications involving Rs 68.789 crore concerned supplies made before ARO issuance.
- Crystal Crop sought approval to invest AUD 20,000 in its Australian wholly owned subsidiary, but the required NOC had not been granted.
powered by IRIS

Crystal Crop Protection faces a December 24, 2021 Central Bureau of Investigation, or CBI, chargesheet alleging Rs 75.531 crore of fraudulent terminal excise-duty, or TED, refunds from 101 applications. The proceedings remain pending, while the related first information report has prevented no-objection certificates for proposed investments in Australia and Bangladesh.
How did Crystal Crop's CBI refund case arise?
Crystal Crop's CBI case arose from allegations that TED refund claims breached the Foreign Trade Policy 2009-2014 and the Directorate General of Foreign Trade, or DGFT, Handbook of Procedures. The CBI Additional Crime Branch, Gandhinagar, registered a first information report, or FIR, on January 18, 2020, under provisions relating to criminal conspiracy and cheating in the erstwhile Indian Penal Code, 1860, and misconduct provisions in the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988.
The FIR names Crystal Crop, individual promoters Nand Kishore Aggarwal and Ankur Aggarwal, who is also a director, certain erstwhile directors, Bhadresh Trading Corporation Limited and others. The matter concerns duty-free import authorisation, or DFIA, licences acquired from Bhadresh Trading under an April 30, 2012 tripartite agreement amended on January 20, 2016. Under the amended agreement, Crystal Crop agreed to pay Bhadresh Trading 60% of TED refunds received in respect of supplies made under the DFIA licences.
Crystal Crop sought advance release orders, or AROs, from DGFT Mumbai to facilitate domestic procurement from Modern Papers, a group entity described as availing an area-based excise-duty exemption. The CBI alleges that claims were made for supplies before ARO issuance and for goods on which excise duty had not actually been paid. TED refunds are intended to refund excise duty paid on eligible supplies, making the timing of supplies and payment of duty central to the allegations.
What do Crystal Crop's 101 refund applications show?
Crystal Crop received Rs 110.325 crore from 101 TED-refund applications sanctioned and released between 2014 and 2016, while the CBI chargesheet alleges that Rs 75.531 crore was fraudulently claimed. The alleged wrongful amount is therefore distinct from the full amount sanctioned and released to Crystal Crop.
The chargesheet attributes the alleged Rs 75.531 crore to Rs 68.789 crore linked to 68 applications for supplies before ARO issuance and Rs 6.742 crore relating to the pre-ARO portion of 10 mixed-supply applications. The same 10 applications included Rs 9.094 crore relating to supplies after ARO issuance, while 23 applications involving Rs 25.700 crore concerned supplies made after the AROs. The application-stage split explains why the chargesheet's alleged amount is lower than the aggregate refund amount released.
Got a follow-up? Ask IRIS
What is the status of Crystal Crop's CBI proceedings?
Crystal Crop's criminal and regulatory proceedings remain pending, with no final adjudication disclosed in the prospectus. The CBI filed its December 24, 2021 chargesheet before the Court of the Special Judge, CBI, Ahmedabad, against the accused persons, including former employees, the consultant associated with the tripartite agreement, Bhadresh Trading and its directors, subject to the qualifications set out in the prospectus.
Crystal Crop has filed discharge applications against the chargesheet and a complaint filed by the Enforcement Directorate, or ED. The CBI and ED have filed replies, and the discharge applications are pending at different stages of adjudication. A discharge application seeks release from a criminal proceeding before trial, and its filing does not determine whether the allegations have been established.
The disclosed risk extends beyond the Rs 75.531 crore alleged TED refund claim. Crystal Crop says an adverse outcome could result in fines or imprisonment for individuals, director disqualification, confiscation of attached assets, further attachment of properties or bank balances, restrictions on banking arrangements, increased compliance costs and reputational damage. These are potential consequences disclosed by Crystal Crop, rather than penalties stated to have already been imposed.
How has the CBI case affected Crystal Crop's overseas investment plans?
The pending CBI FIR has affected Crystal Crop's ability to obtain mandatory no-objection certificates, or NOCs, for proposed overseas investments under Rule 10 of the Foreign Exchange Management (Overseas Investment) Rules, 2022. Rule 10 requires an NOC before a foreign investment when an investigation is pending against a company, linking the unresolved proceeding directly to Crystal Crop's overseas investment plans.
Crystal Crop filed a writ petition before the Gujarat High Court seeking directions for an NOC to invest AUD 20,000 in Crystal Crop Protection, (Australia) Pty Limited, its wholly owned subsidiary, for statutory and operational expenses. The prospectus states that the NOC had not been granted because the FIR and associated complaints remained pending in relevant courts. The proposed funding could not proceed through the stated route without the required clearance.
Crystal Crop also applied to the CBI on June 24, 2025 for an NOC to establish and invest in a wholly owned Bangladesh subsidiary. It subsequently filed a Gujarat High Court writ petition dated October 2, 2025 seeking a direction to the CBI superintendent of police to decide that application. The restriction may continue unless the relevant authority grants the NOC or a court provides the requested relief, and the prospectus provides no timetable for either event.
Conclusion
The disclosed matter combines a CBI allegation involving Rs 75.531 crore of TED refunds with a regulatory constraint on overseas investments. Crystal Crop received Rs 110.325 crore across 101 applications, but the chargesheet identifies alleged wrongful claims associated with pre-ARO supplies and the pre-ARO portion of mixed-supply applications. The pending proceedings may therefore have implications for overseas funding, banking arrangements, assets, governance and reputation if an adverse outcome occurs.
The next disclosed developments to watch are decisions on Crystal Crop's discharge applications, the related ED complaint and the two NOC requests. The June 24, 2025 Bangladesh NOC application and the October 2, 2025 Gujarat High Court petition are identified procedural markers. Any decision on the AUD 20,000 Australian subsidiary investment would also indicate whether the overseas-investment constraint has changed.


