Crystal Crop faces Rs 30.21 crore ED attachment in TED case
Key highlights
- The CBI charge-sheet alleges Rs 20.626 crore of wrongful loss to the exchequer from Crystal Crop's TED refunds.
- The ED disclosure identifies Rs 30.206 crore of fixed-deposit attachment in the investigation.
- The ED encashed Rs 9.94 crore of Crystal Crop fixed deposits during the six months ended 30 September 2025.
- Crystal Crop filed its CBI discharge application on 20 February 2023 and has made no accounting adjustment for the case.
powered by IRIS

Crystal Crop Protection Limited faces an unresolved terminal excise duty refund case in which the Enforcement Directorate disclosure identifies Rs 30.206 crore of fixed-deposit attachment, while the Central Bureau of Investigation alleges Rs 20.626 crore of wrongful loss to the exchequer. Crystal Crop disputes the allegations and has recorded no accounting adjustment.
What is Crystal Crop's TED-refund case and ED attachment?
Crystal Crop's terminal excise duty, or TED, dispute concerns refunds received between May 2012 and May 2015. Show-cause notices issued during financial year 2019-20 by the Additional Director General of Foreign Trade questioned whether refunds received in the years ended 31 March 2015 and 31 March 2016 complied with the Foreign Trade Policy and its amendments.
The last cited notice, dated 5 November 2019, demanded repayment of Rs 10.917 crore plus interest for TED refunds received from May 2012 to May 2015. The notices referred to documents described as AROs as the basis for the alleged ineligibility. Crystal Crop challenged the notices in the Gujarat High Court and disclosed that it had obtained a stay on the demands.
The ED proceedings followed a Central Bureau of Investigation, or CBI, first information report and charge-sheet. The ED initially attached a Crystal Crop fixed deposit of Rs 2.066 crore on 7 January 2021, and Crystal Crop appealed the 15 May 2022 attachment order before the Appellate Tribunal under the Prevention of Money-Laundering Act, 2002, or PMLA.
How did the CBI proceedings arise for Crystal Crop?
The CBI charge-sheet alleges wrongful TED refunds and invalid AROs, implicating Crystal Crop, its directors and former Directorate General of Foreign Trade officials. The charge-sheet alleges a wrongful loss of Rs 20.626 crore to the exchequer, which is distinct from the Rs 10.917 crore administrative repayment demand plus interest in the 5 November 2019 notice.
Crystal Crop filed a discharge application before the CBI Court in Ahmedabad on 20 February 2023. A discharge application seeks release from a criminal case before trial. The disclosure listed 13 January 2026 as the hearing date for that application, while the separately mentioned CBI Court case was listed for hearing on 8 December 2025.
The distinction among the figures matters because they describe separate legal measures. The foreign-trade notice seeks repayment of specified refunds, the CBI figure is the alleged loss attributed to the exchequer, and the ED amounts relate to attachments and encashment during a money-laundering investigation. None of those figures is disclosed as a final court-determined liability.
What money has the ED attached or encashed from Crystal Crop?
The ED's investigation, as described in a 9 October 2024 press release and a provisional supplementary complaint, resulted in additional provisional attachment of proceeds described as fixed deposits. The disclosure identifies Rs 4.99 crore pertaining to Crystal Crop, Rs 30.206 crore of fixed deposits, and Rs 3.786 crore pertaining to Page Rameshchandra Rathor, another alleged person in the case.
The same disclosure refers to Rs 41.533 crore related to a stop-work matter involving Bhavya Trading Corporation Limited. That amount is reported alongside the ED's broader investigation and should not be combined with Crystal Crop's Rs 10.917 crore TED repayment demand, because the note does not present them as one liability or one attachment attributable solely to Crystal Crop.
During the six months ended 30 September 2025, the ED encashed Crystal Crop fixed deposits of Rs 9.94 crore. Crystal Crop challenged that encashment before the PMLA Appellate Tribunal, stating that there was no reference to an offence committed; the disclosure listed 13 January 2026 as the hearing date.
Got a follow-up? Ask IRIS
Does Crystal Crop expect a financial impact from the TED case?
Crystal Crop has not adjusted its restated consolidated financial information for the TED, CBI or ED proceedings. Management stated that, after considering available information and legal assessments, it believed it had a favourable case for claiming the refunds, that convictions for the offences alleged by the CBI and ED were unlikely, and that the attachment would be vacated.
That accounting position is management's assessment, not a conclusion by a court or investigating agency. The disclosure states that the ED investigation had not concluded as of the six months ended 30 September 2025, so a different legal outcome, additional enforcement action or an adverse order could affect the assessment that no adjustment was required.
Crystal Crop's contingent-liability table reported excise-duty matters of Rs 28.941 crore at 30 September 2025, compared with Rs 7.616 crore at 31 March 2025 and nil at 31 March 2024. The table says quantified interest and penalties are included where applicable, but it aggregates excise-duty proceedings and does not identify the TED case as a separately recognised provision.
How does the TED matter compare with Crystal Crop's other contingencies?
Crystal Crop reported an entry-tax contingency of Rs 69.20 crore at both 30 September 2025 and 31 March 2025, exceeding the Rs 28.941 crore excise-duty category. Six Haryana entry-tax show-cause notices dated 22 January 2025 proposed a demand of Rs 29.61 crore for financial years 2012-13 to 2017-18 under the Haryana Entry Tax Act, 2008.
Crystal Crop stated that the Punjab and Haryana High Court had stayed adjudication of the entry-tax notices. The company filed a writ petition in March 2025, and the disclosure listed 16 December 2025 for its hearing. Management described the notices as unconstitutional, time-barred and unenforceable, and therefore made no adjustment in the restated financial information.
Other 30 September 2025 contingent-liability categories included goods and services tax of Rs 12.384 crore, income tax of Rs 4.689 crore, customs duty of Rs 3.986 crore and consumer matters of Rs 3.053 crore. Unlike those aggregated ordinary-course claims, the TED matter combines a stayed refund demand, CBI criminal proceedings, an ongoing ED investigation and the encashment of Rs 9.94 crore in fixed deposits.
Conclusion
Crystal Crop's TED-refund matter extends beyond the Rs 10.917 crore repayment demand in the 5 November 2019 notice. It includes a CBI allegation of Rs 20.626 crore in wrongful loss, an ED disclosure of Rs 30.206 crore in fixed-deposit attachment and Rs 9.94 crore of deposits encashed in the six months ended 30 September 2025, while Crystal Crop maintains that no accounting adjustment is required.
The matters to watch are the outcomes of the CBI Court and discharge proceedings, the PMLA Appellate Tribunal challenge to the attachment and encashment, and the still-unconcluded ED investigation. The disclosure listed 8 December 2025 for the CBI Court case and 13 January 2026 for both the discharge application and PMLA appellate matter; any subsequent orders could test management's expectation that the attachments will be vacated.


