Tata Motors Passenger Vehicles Limited trails Nifty over five years
Key highlights
- TMPV's five-year return is reported between -6.2% and -50.5% across the supplied data sources.
- One comparison shows TMPV down 50.44% over five years while the Nifty 50 gained 42.43%.
- A five-year CAGR table shows ₹10,000 in TMPV becoming ₹6,101, versus ₹14,127 in the Nifty 50.
- The BSE and NSE reports list TMPV's one-year decline at about 30%.
powered by IRIS

Tata Motors Passenger Vehicles Limited has underperformed the Nifty 50 over the latest five-year measures in the supplied market reports, with its five-year return listed as low as -50.5% against a 42.43% Nifty 50 gain. The reported figures differ by data provider and measurement date, but all cited comparisons show weak recent shareholder performance.
What was TMPV's five-year stock return?
TMPV's reported five-year return ranges from a 6.2% decline to a 50.5% decline across the supplied reports, making the measurement date and return methodology important. One BSE report lists a five-year change of -47.61%, while its NSE counterpart lists -47.69%. A separate historical-return summary puts the five-year figure at -50.5%.
Other supplied price-history data gives less severe outcomes. One report says TMPV fell 17.60% over five years and shows a five-year stock-price CAGR of -4%. Another weekly-close comparison, dated 13 November 2026, puts the five-year decline at 6.2%, based on a close of ₹287.40 versus ₹306.32 five years earlier. These are not interchangeable figures because the reports use different dates and may use different return conventions.
How did TMPV compare with the Nifty 50?
TMPV lagged the Nifty 50 in every five-year benchmark comparison supplied in the discussion. The clearest absolute-return comparison shows TMPV down 50.44% over five years while the Nifty 50 rose 42.43%, a gap of nearly 93 percentage points between the two outcomes.
The weekly-close dataset also shows underperformance, though with a different stock return figure. It says TMPV was down 6.2% over five years, while the Nifty 500 was up 53.2%. Its holding-period table estimates a five-year CAGR of -9.4% for TMPV, reducing ₹10,000 to ₹6,101, against ₹14,127 in the Nifty 50. That table reinforces the relative result even as its calculation differs from the reported weekly price change.
Got a follow-up? Ask IRIS
Why do TMPV's five-year return figures differ?
TMPV's five-year figures differ because the supplied sources present returns from different observation dates and formats, without enough detail to reconcile every calculation. The inputs range from current BSE and NSE prices around ₹259 in one set of reports to a 13 November 2026 weekly close of ₹287.40 in another. A five-year return changes with the exact start and end date.
The reports also label results differently, including price change, absolute return, total return and CAGR. One item refers to a 547.2% five-year total return, including a 542.28% price return and 4.92% dividend return, which conflicts sharply with the other TMPV data supplied. Investors should therefore avoid treating that figure as directly comparable with the negative five-year price-return series without verifying the underlying security, period and methodology.
Conclusion
The consistent message across the supplied TMPV discussions is relative underperformance over the recent five-year period. Whether the reported decline is 6.2%, 17.6%, about 48%, or 50.5%, each cited benchmark comparison places the stock behind the Nifty 50 or Nifty 500. The variation itself is a reminder that return figures need a clear end date and definition.
The next point to watch is whether later price data can establish a consistent five-year comparison after the stock's recent decline. The supplied reports show TMPV at or close to its 52-week lows of ₹259.00 to ₹259.20 in one data set, while another records a 52-week weekly low of ₹264.60, leaving the choice of data source and measurement period unresolved.


