Concord Enviro NCLT dismisses Rs 1.76 crore insolvency plea
Key highlights
- The Mumbai NCLT dismissed the Rs 1.76 crore Section 9 application against Rochem on 6 November 2026.
- Concord Enviro disclosed the dismissal on 19 November 2026; Rochem is its wholly owned subsidiary.
- NeSL recorded the Rs 1.76 crore debt as “DISPUTED” on 10 September 2024.
- The tribunal cited Rochem’s 14 August 2023 dispute reply as predating the February 2024 demand notice.
powered by IRIS

Concord Enviro Systems Limited said the Mumbai Bench of the National Company Law Tribunal dismissed a Section 9 insolvency application seeking Rs 1.76 crore from its wholly owned subsidiary, Rochem Separation Systems (India) Private Limited, because the record showed a pre-existing dispute over the claimed debt before the demand notice.
Know Concord Enviro Systems inside out
Results, valuation, peers and who's buying, in one view.
What did the Mumbai NCLT decide in the Rochem case?
The National Company Law Tribunal, Mumbai Bench, dismissed and disposed of RCP(IB)/24(MB)2025 on 6 November 2026, the Section 9 application filed by Ketav Consultant against Rochem Separation Systems (India) Private Limited. Concord Enviro disclosed the outcome to the exchanges on 19 November 2026 under Regulation 30 of the Securities and Exchange Board of India (Listing Obligations and Disclosure Requirements) Regulations, 2015.
The application concerned an alleged outstanding amount of Rs 1.76 crore for evaporator plant parts and related products supplied to Rochem. The tribunal recorded that the operational creditor described the amount as unpaid invoices and stated that Rs 1.76 crore, including interest, remained due; it ultimately dismissed the insolvency application rather than admitting it.
Rochem is a wholly owned subsidiary of Concord Enviro, according to the company’s 19 November 2026 announcement. The order sheet identifies the case as Ketav Consultant versus Rochem Separation Systems India Private Limited and records appearances for both the petitioner and respondent at the 6 November hearing.
Why did the NCLT dismiss the Section 9 application?
The NCLT dismissed the application because it found that Rochem had disputed the Rs 1.76 crore claim before the relevant demand notice was issued. The tribunal said the facts demonstrated a pre-existing dispute over whether the claimed amount was due and payable, which prevented the Section 9 process from proceeding in this case.
A Form D record of default issued through NeSL, the information utility named in the order, listed the status of authentication as “DISPUTED” on 10 September 2024. The record showed a default date of 8 July 2023, a total outstanding amount of Rs 1.76 crore and the dispute remark: “No such debt existed.”
The tribunal also considered correspondence around a Form 3 demand notice dated 13 February 2024 and dispatched on 15 February 2024. Rochem responded through its advocate on 27 February 2024, referring to earlier notices and exchanges, and maintained that the claim was based on vague and unilateral computations that it did not accept.
The order referred to Rochem’s reply dated 14 August 2023, which disputed the claimed debt before the February 2024 Form 3 notice. It also cited Salil Musale v. Lintec India Pvt. Ltd. and Ors., a 2026 National Company Law Appellate Tribunal decision, for the proposition that a Section 9 application is not maintainable where a notice of dispute predates and also responds to the demand notice, while the information-utility record identifies the debt as disputed.
Got a follow-up? Ask IRIS
What amount was claimed and how did the parties’ figures differ?
Ketav Consultant’s Section 9 application sought Rs 1.76 crore, but the documents reviewed by the NCLT showed differing figures in the parties’ correspondence. The tribunal noted that the creditor’s 15 November 2021 email attached a statement showing total dues of Rs 2.13 crore, rather than the Rs 1.76 crore later claimed in the insolvency application.
The tribunal recorded that Rochem had sent an account statement from 1 April 2017 to 7 December 2021 and asked the creditor to reconcile its account in Rochem’s books. In a 7 December 2021 email, Rochem said it would begin releasing outstanding payments after 15 December 2021, while seeking the requested reconciliation.
On 28 January 2022 and 25 August 2022, Rochem sought confirmation of the balance due as reflected in its books. The creditor responded with claimed balances of Rs 1.65 crore and Rs 2.00 crore, respectively, and disputed the amount recorded as payable in Rochem’s books, according to the order.
The creditor relied on those emails as acknowledgements of debt for extending the limitation period and as admissions that the amount was undisputed. The NCLT did not accept that characterisation without qualification, finding that the emails asked for reconciliation and could constitute admissions only for an amount, if any, actually payable under those communications.
What does the order mean for Concord Enviro and Rochem?
The order removes this particular Section 9 insolvency application against Rochem, the wholly owned subsidiary identified in Concord Enviro’s disclosure. It does not state that the tribunal determined a final payable amount between the parties; its stated basis for dismissal was the existence of a dispute before the insolvency demand notice.
The NCLT’s analysis was tied to the specific Rs 1.76 crore claim, the 14 August 2023 dispute communication, the 27 February 2024 reply to the Form 3 demand notice and the NeSL status marked “DISPUTED.” These dated records were central to the tribunal’s finding that the case was not maintainable as a Section 9 application.
Concord Enviro’s filing was a continuation of an earlier intimation dated 4 July 2025. The company attached the tribunal order after receiving a system-generated email notification on 19 November 2026 and downloading the order from the NCLT website, rather than providing financial guidance or a separate estimate of any accounting effect.
Conclusion
The 6 November 2026 order means the Rs 1.76 crore insolvency route initiated by Ketav Consultant against Rochem has been dismissed, following the NCLT’s finding that the debt was already disputed. For Concord Enviro, the disclosed event concerns a wholly owned subsidiary and turns on the procedural requirement that a Section 9 claim cannot proceed where a pre-existing dispute is evidenced in correspondence and the NeSL record.
What remains to watch is the unresolved payment disagreement reflected in the parties’ 2021 to 2024 correspondence, as the order does not determine a final amount payable. Concord Enviro’s 19 November 2026 disclosure does not set out a planned appeal, settlement, financial impact or further hearing date after dismissal of RCP(IB)/24(MB)2025.


