Mahanadi Coalfields promoter's CCI appeals remain unresolved
Key highlights
- The NCLAT has stayed the CCI’s March 24, 2017 order and its Rs 591 crore penalty against Coal India Limited.
- The Supreme Court held on June 15, 2023 that the Competition Act applies to Coal India Limited and its subsidiaries.
- The original Rs 1,773 crore CCI penalty of December 9, 2013 was set aside by COMPAT on May 17, 2016 for procedural reasons.
- The NCLAT said on November 20, 2025 that additional grounds would be heard with the connected FSA appeals.
powered by IRIS

Mahanadi Coalfields Limited’s corporate promoter, Coal India Limited, still faces unresolved appeals against Competition Commission of India findings of abuse of dominance, including a Rs 591 crore fuel-supply penalty stayed by the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal. The Supreme Court held on June 15, 2023 that the Competition Act, 2002 applies to Coal India Limited and its subsidiaries, but returned the individual disputes for decisions on their merits.
Why do Mahanadi Coalfields’ promoter CCI appeals remain unresolved?
Mahanadi Coalfields’ promoter CCI appeals remain unresolved because the June 15, 2023 Supreme Court judgment decided that the Competition Act applies to Coal India Limited and its subsidiaries, without deciding whether the specific coal-sale terms amounted to abuse. Coal India Limited is disclosed as Mahanadi Coalfields’ corporate promoter, and the proceedings described in the prospectus are against Coal India Limited and, in some cases, its subsidiaries.
The procedural route has prolonged the merits cases. Coal India Limited filed a transfer petition on August 7, 2019 while similar appeals were pending before the Supreme Court and the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal, or NCLAT. The Supreme Court transferred NCLAT matters to itself on March 22, 2023, then returned them to their respective forums after its June 15, 2023 ruling. The Supreme Court retains two stated appeals, while several other matters are again before the NCLAT.
The Competition Commission of India, or CCI, examined alleged violations of Section 4(2)(a)(i) of the Competition Act, which addresses unfair or discriminatory conditions in the purchase or sale of goods or services. The disclosed cases cover fuel supply agreements, the Spot E-Auction Scheme for non-coking coal, letters of assurance, memorandums of understanding and coal-quality procedures. Each proceeding therefore requires a separate merits decision despite the Supreme Court’s ruling on the law’s applicability.
What is the status of the Rs 591 crore fuel-supply penalty?
The Rs 591 crore penalty is stayed, and Coal India Limited’s appeal against the CCI’s March 24, 2017 revised order remains pending before the NCLAT. The case began with information filed in 2012 by Maharashtra State Power Generation Company Limited, or Mahagenco, against Coal India Limited and Mahanadi Coalfields, followed by related information involving Western Coalfields Limited and Gujarat State Electricity Corporation Limited.
The CCI’s first order, dated December 9, 2013, found Coal India Limited in contravention of Section 4(2)(a)(i) and imposed a Rs 1,773 crore penalty. The former Competition Appellate Tribunal, or COMPAT, set aside that order on May 17, 2016 because the CCI members issuing the final decision were not the same members who had heard oral arguments. The tribunal remanded the matter for de novo consideration, meaning a fresh consideration by a properly constituted bench.
After the remand, the CCI again found abuse in its March 24, 2017 order but lowered the penalty to Rs 591 crore. The CCI cited remedial measures by Coal India Limited to improve coal sampling and amend certain fuel supply agreement provisions, as well as operating constraints arising from government directives. The NCLAT stay covers both the revised order and the penalty, so the source does not describe the Rs 591 crore as a currently enforceable payment.
The allegations concerned terms in fuel supply agreements, or FSAs, including grade slippage, sampling methods, ungraded coal, compensation for stones and oversized coal, termination provisions, force majeure and absence of bilateral negotiations. Grade slippage concerns supply below the contracted coal grade, while sampling determines the quality assessment process. The appeal’s outcome will depend on the treatment of those contract terms, the remedial measures cited by the CCI and the relevance of government-directed operating conditions.
Got a follow-up? Ask IRIS
Which Mahanadi Coalfields promoter practices did the CCI examine?
The CCI examined several distinct coal-sale practices involving Coal India Limited, rather than one uniform allegation across all coal transactions. In the Sai Wardha Power Limited matter, the CCI’s October 27, 2014 order said Coal India Limited’s dominant position arose from the statutory regime under the Coal Mines (Nationalization) Act, 1973. COMPAT dismissed Coal India Limited’s appeal on December 9, 2016, and Appeal No. 2845 of 2017 remains pending before the Supreme Court.
A separate October 27, 2014 CCI order concerned non-coking coal sold under the Spot E-Auction Scheme after information filed by Bijay Poddar on July 18, 2013. The CCI found abuse through allegedly unfair and discriminatory sale conditions. COMPAT upheld the findings and directed amendments to the scheme on March 20, 2017, but the Supreme Court granted an interim stay of that order on May 5, 2017. Coal India Limited’s appeal remains pending before the Supreme Court.
In a separate group of FSA cases, the CCI found abuse relating to drafting and finalising agreements, grade declaration and review, supplies under memorandums of understanding, deemed delivery quantity adjustments and ungraded coal. The April 21, 2017 CCI order involving Madhya Pradesh Power Generating Company Limited, West Bengal Power Development Corporation Limited and the Sponge Iron Manufacturers Association imposed no separate penalty. The CCI said a penalty for identical conduct had already been imposed in the Mahagenco-connected matter.
The GHCL Limited case remains before the NCLAT and covers letters of assurance, reductions in annual contracted quantity through memorandums of understanding, security deposits, coal guarantees, sampling and grade review. The prospectus also records a Karnataka Power Corporation Limited appeal. The CCI dismissed Karnataka Power’s March 8, 2017 information because it considered the issues already adjudicated in Case No. 03 of 2012, but the subsequent appeal remains pending before the NCLAT.
What procedural decisions should Mahanadi Coalfields readers watch?
The principal procedural issue before the NCLAT is whether Coal India Limited can pursue additional grounds alongside the merits of its connected FSA appeals. Coal India Limited filed interlocutory applications on July 19, 2024, seeking leave to add grounds including reliance on the Administrative Mechanism for Resolution of Central Public Sector Enterprise Disputes, or AMRCD, Guidelines. Respondents challenged the maintainability of those applications when they were listed on July 22, 2024.
The NCLAT clarified on November 20, 2025 that the additional grounds in the appeals involving power generators and the Sponge Iron Manufacturers Association would be heard with the main appeals. That direction does not affirm, modify or set aside the CCI findings; it sets the scope of the hearing. The merits determination must still address the CCI’s conclusions on FSA terms and Coal India Limited’s grounds of challenge.
In the Karnataka Power matter, the informant sought linking and consolidation with Competition Appeal (AT) Nos. 1-3, 11 and 12 of 2017. Coal India Limited filed its reply on January 9, 2026, and the NCLAT had made no determination on that application as of the disclosed date. The case was listed separately with those appeals, leaving consolidation and the substantive appeal unresolved.
Conclusion
Mahanadi Coalfields’ disclosed promoter litigation shows that the applicability of competition law is settled, but the outcomes of the underlying coal-supply disputes are not. Coal India Limited faces pending appeals concerning FSAs, e-auction conditions and related supply mechanisms; the Rs 591 crore FSA penalty remains stayed, while the Spot E-Auction Scheme order remains subject to the Supreme Court’s May 5, 2017 interim stay.
The next developments to watch are the NCLAT’s merits hearings after its November 20, 2025 direction on additional grounds, any ruling on the Karnataka consolidation application, and progress in the two Supreme Court appeals. Those proceedings will determine whether the CCI findings, remedial directions and stayed penalty are sustained, changed or set aside.


