Mahanadi Coalfields Limited reports recurring control gaps
Key highlights
- MCL reported total assets of Rs 57,711.68 crore at September 30, 2026.
- MCL disclosed no insurance for specified asset categories, stores and coal stock in FY2024, FY2025 and FY2026.
- Income-tax refunds of Rs 3,617.27 crore for assessment years 2009-10 to 2023-24 were pending at March 31, 2025.
- MCL’s May 31, 2023 forensic-audit report had not been placed before the Board through the Audit Committee in the FY2025 disclosure.
powered by IRIS

Mahanadi Coalfields Limited reported recurring control gaps in audit disclosures, including no insurance for specified asset categories other than limited equipment exceptions, unresolved tax reconciliations and an unplaced forensic-audit report. Its consolidated total assets stood at Rs 57,711.68 crore on September 30, 2026, while the underlying audit opinions remained unmodified.
Why did auditors flag MCL’s insurance and control gaps?
Auditors flagged MCL’s insurance and control gaps because the company disclosed that it had not taken insurance cover for assets, property, plant and equipment, stores and spares, and closing coal stock against fire, burglary and allied risks. For FY2026, the stated exceptions were heavy earth-moving machinery, or HEMM, plying on roads and light vehicles.
The insurance observation appeared in each of the FY2024, FY2025 and FY2026 audit disclosures. The FY2025 wording exempted some HEMM and road-going vehicles, while the FY2024 disclosure similarly referred to fixed assets, stores and spares, and closing coal stock without cover except certain HEMM and vehicles plying on roads. The disclosures establish recurrence across three annual reporting periods, but do not quantify any uninsured loss or the value of assets within the exceptions.
MCL reported property, plant and equipment of Rs 18,308.10 crore and inventories of Rs 1,255.78 crore at September 30, 2026. These balance-sheet categories provide scale for the insurance observation, although the audit wording does not say that every item reported in either category lacked cover. The issue would change only if MCL obtains insurance for the categories identified in the audit disclosures.
How did MCL’s assets and inventories change in 2026?
MCL’s total assets increased to Rs 57,711.68 crore at September 30, 2026 from Rs 55,358.27 crore at March 31, 2026, although inventories declined by Rs 983.24 crore over the six-month period. Property, plant and equipment also fell by Rs 211.42 crore from the March 2026 balance, whereas other bank balances increased by Rs 3,449.76 crore.
MCL’s property, plant and equipment at September 30, 2026 was nevertheless Rs 1,944.39 crore higher than at March 31, 2025. Separately, the FY2026 audit report said MCL depreciates certain equipment using useful lives determined by management or Coal India Limited through technical evaluation, which may differ from the useful lives under Schedule II of the Companies Act, 2013. That accounting-policy disclosure is separate from the insurance matter but affects the carrying values of equipment.
Which tax reconciliations remained unresolved at MCL?
MCL had not reconciled tax deducted at source, or TDS, and tax collected at source, or TCS, receivables in its books with Form 26AS and the Annual Information Statement as of March 31, 2025. Auditors also said the Goods and Services Tax, or GST, electronic credit ledger balance on the GST portal had not been reconciled with the books at that date.
The FY2025 audit disclosure further said TDS, TCS and GST payable balances included amounts related to earlier periods that remained unreconciled at the balance-sheet date. Auditors did not quantify the unmatched component of those balances or state that a financial-statement adjustment was required. Completion depends on matching book balances with tax records and resolving any differences.
Income-tax refunds represented a separate administrative matter. Refunds for assessment years 2009-10 through 2023-24 totalling Rs 3,617.27 crore were pending with the Income Tax Department at March 31, 2025, compared with Rs 3,392 crore for assessment years 2019-20 through 2023-24 at March 31, 2024. MCL reported current tax assets of Rs 652.12 crore at September 30, 2026, but the supplied financial statements do not link that balance directly to the pending-refund figure.
Got a follow-up? Ask IRIS
What happened to MCL’s forensic-audit report?
A forensic audit of MCL’s coal-sales realisation from April 1, 2008 to June 22, 2019 reported losses from alleged manipulation or fraudulent entries in books of account, according to the audit disclosures. The forensic auditor issued its report on May 31, 2023, and the FY2025 audit disclosure said the report had yet to be placed before MCL’s Board through the Audit Committee.
The reported governance status remained unresolved in the two annual audit disclosures. For FY2024, auditors said the forensic report had not been adopted; for FY2025, they said it had not been placed before the Board through the Audit Committee. Neither disclosure states the monetary value of the reported loss, identifies coal customers involved, or records a recovery, provision or disciplinary action.
MCL also did not undertake verification of stores and spares in FY2024 or FY2025. The audit disclosures said that items more than 10 years old had a 50% provision, but their operational lives had not been assessed. The source does not give the value of the older items, so it does not quantify any potential inventory valuation effect.
Did MCL’s audit warnings modify the audit opinion?
No, MCL’s insurance, reconciliation and forensic-report disclosures did not modify the underlying audit opinions for FY2024, FY2025, FY2026 or the six months ended September 30, 2026. The restated consolidated financial-information report says the underlying audit reports were not modified, while Annexure 1 separately sets out emphasis-of-matter and other-matter disclosures.
For FY2026, auditors also reported Rs 76.55 crore of unplanned depreciation charged during the year relating to FY2024 and FY2025, based on Comptroller and Auditor General observations. MCL also started claiming eligible input tax credit, or ITC, on capital expenditure from April 1, 2025, except ITC on laptops and mobiles; until FY2025, it had capitalised such ITC as part of property, plant and equipment.
The consolidated audit also relied on reports from other auditors for four subsidiaries. Those subsidiaries reported total assets of Rs 633.39 crore, total income of Rs 92.61 crore and group share of profit of Rs 69.52 crore in FY2026. This reliance was disclosed as an other matter and was not presented as a qualification of the consolidated audit opinion.
Conclusion
MCL’s audit disclosures show recurring control matters alongside unmodified audit opinions. The insurance observation covered major asset categories in FY2024 through FY2026, while the FY2025 disclosures identified unreconciled tax balances, incomplete balance confirmations, unverified stores and an unresolved process for the May 2023 forensic report. The Rs 57,711.68 crore total asset base at September 30, 2026 indicates the scale of the group without quantifying any resulting loss.
The next disclosures to watch are whether MCL arranges insurance for the cited asset categories, completes TDS, TCS and GST reconciliations, verifies stores and spares, and places the forensic report before its Board through the Audit Committee. MCL also said it was assessing the effect of four labour codes, with no accounting adjustment until relevant rules are notified or direction is received from Coal India Limited.


